On September 25, 2026, Taylor Swift surprised fans with four new bonus tracks from her latest album. Called The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore, the Grammy Award-winning singer released the tracks Patient Zero, Cleveland, Pink Clouding and Babylon. While a few of her loyal fan base loved the new tracks, many found tracks like Cleveland to be lacking the previous artistry of Swift’s previous works. Others went a step ahead and created a conspiracy in which they imagined Patient Zero to be about Swift’s ex Joe Jonas and his former wife, Sophie Turner, who also happens to be the singer’s bestie. Here’s what the divided fans had to say.
